Progresive Insurance Does Not Deserve Your Business
This post originally appeared on PR Breakfast Club on August 14th, 2012.
I’m fortunate to be connected to hundreds of outstanding public relations and marketing professionals. All of them are fantastic at their job, and I’m a smarter person for just knowing them (that includes the proprietor of this blog, and the many contributors). Given all the good I see the industry accomplishing each day, at least one a month it seems an entity or a person commits such an egregious screw up that I’m left to question the future of public relations. Or at least how these people have a job that pays them more than minimum wage. The subject of today’s post is Progressive Insurance.
I’ll get right to the point. According to this Gawker article, Progressive paid to defend the killer of one of their client’s in court. Read that sentence again. Notice I didn’t say “basically” or “in essence”. No. This company paid its lawyers to defend a guy who ran a red light and killed Katie Fisher.Comedian (ironic, huh?) Matt Fisher, Katie’s brother, documented the entire situation in this Tumblr post. What happened boiled down to this. The perpetrator was underinsured, but his insurance company paid what was due to Katie’s family under its policy, which was still short. The Progressive policy that Katie had entitled her loved ones to more compensation. Progressive said no. Katie’s parents were forced to sue the other driver, and who showed up to defend him in court? Progressive’s lawyers.
Understandably, Matt Fisher was PISSED. So, he wrote about it on Tumblr yesterday, and what did Progressive do to respond to all the negative attention it got on Twitter? Respond in a human manner? Take responsibility for the TERRIBLE job it did at using human reason rather than a contract to determine what it needed to do? Oh no. Of course not:
This is a tragic case, and our sympathies go out to Mr. Fisher and his family for the pain they’ve had to endure. We fully investigated this claim and relevant background, and feel we properly handled the claim within our contractual obligations. Again, this is a tragic situation, and we’re sorry for everything Mr. Fisher and his family have gone through.
Beyond the stock response, which is a huge middle finger to anyone upset with Progressive in this situation, this is what happens when the PR department does nothing to stand up to the legal department. I get that each company has legal obligations and contracts, and it must adhere to those. When a person is dead, and the only (for lack of a better word) comfort the surviving family members get is settlement money, I am of the opinion that you have a moral obligation to expedite the process (while doing due diligence) to help ease their pain.
I’m fortunate enough to never have lost someone I’m close to, though that day is coming. I can’t imagine the extra pain the Fisher family was forced to endure in this situation. Truly, every PR failure in this situation can be fixed with one sentence.
Act like human beings.
Read the comments section. They are absolutely making very relevant points. Here are a couple:
- With every stock answer tweet Progressive sends out with Flo’s face next to it, they are destroying that lovable character they’ve spent YEARS and (I’m assuming here) millions of dollars to build.
- The fact that Progressive extends empathy to the family when the company itself is a big part of the pain of the family.
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
- RT @leap36: Lost my IPad mini at toys-r-us today in Gurnee,Illinois,you will get a reward if you find it, it's in a denim case,email LBTV3… 4 hours ago
- RT @edsbs: I like taking my glasses off and pretending Copeland is Waka Flocka. 5 hours ago
- @Lord_Beezle There was a warp setting. And it was glorious. 8 hours ago
- I'm at @TheLocalMpls (Minneapolis, MN) w/ 3 others 4sq.com/17M7Um2 9 hours ago
- This was waiting for me in my room. Any ideas? [pic] — path.com/p/3g0f8r 9 hours ago
- Home for the next few days. (@ Hilton Minneapolis - @hiltonhotels w/ 4 others) 4sq.com/12kBadj 9 hours ago
- Greetings Minnesotans. Floyd sends his regards. #Hawkeyes (@ Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport (MSP)) 4sq.com/15WUV13 10 hours ago
- Don’t worry folks. Just because the plane has pulled up doesn’t mean we’re boarding any time soon. 12 hours ago
- RT @keviniewoo: Noted. Twitter Vines Get Shared 4x More Than Online Video via @advertisingweek: adweek.it/11o1p7K 13 hours ago
- @reneehulshof LOOK AT ME! I’M KING OF THE WORLD!!! 1 day ago
- @reneehulshof That said, this situation needs to be made an example of so it doesn’t happen again in the future. 1 day ago
- @reneehulshof That’s the thing. It has zero to do with politics as this has happened in the past with GOP. It’s EVERYONE /bangs head on desk 1 day ago
- @YQJ31 @Garwin7 @karatikki Morning commute a bit longer as i drop the kid off; maybe 20? In a small town, gas prices hurt, more manageable 1 day ago
- @reneehulshof It’s unreal and completely infuriating. This is Stalin type stuff. Everyone in DC holding office should be removed; start over 1 day ago
- So the #IRS defense is, “No, no, no. We’re not partisan! Merely incompetent and stupid!” Gotcha. That’s a winning defense for sure. 1 day ago
- @karatikki @Garwin7 To be fair, my current commute is all of 3-5 minutes depending on traffic. Still. I’d like the option. 1 day ago
- @Garwin7 @karatikki @YQJ31 Fair point. 1 day ago
- @Garwin7 @karatikki @YQJ31 I’m in full favor of everyone working from home. 1 day ago
- @karatikki @YQJ31 @Garwin7 Not how it works, you’re right. But it’s how it SHOULD work. 1 day ago
- @reneehulshof @adriennemay Mind. Blown. 1 day ago
Comments About My Ruminations
|clothing on Could the Survival of Facebook…|
|Cara on Could the Survival of Facebook…|
|http://tinyurl.com/t… on Could the Survival of Facebook…|
|Matt LaCasse on Google+ Will Overtake Facebook…|
|Kirk Hazlett, APR, F… on Google+ Will Overtake Facebook…|